Whether it’s the sizzle of a pizza fresh out of the oven or the sweet dusting of cinnamon on a pretzel, Costco’s food court has long been a treasure trove of affordable and tasty delights that go beyond the bulk buys in its aisles. However, not all menu items have stood the test of time. Over the years, several beloved dishes have disappeared, leaving many members nostalgic and hoping for their return. Here’s a look at some of those cherished food court items, why they were removed, and the fervent fan base that still dreams of their comeback.
The Beloved Combo Pizza
Costco’s combo pizza, loaded with pepperoni, sausage, peppers, mushrooms, and onions, was more than just a meal; it was a cult favorite for its unbeatable price of $9.95 and deliciously hearty toppings. Its disappearance left a gaping hole in the hearts (and stomachs) of many. While the official reason for its removal was never explicitly stated, it is speculated that maintaining its low price point amidst rising costs for ingredients and operations during the pandemic became untenable. Although there’s now a take-and-bake version available in the freezer section, fans agree—it just doesn’t capture the fresh magic of the food court original.
The Sweet and Crunchy Churro
The Costco churro, once a mere dollar treat, was perfect for rounding off a shopping trip. This cinnamon-sugar-coated delight has had a tumultuous history, being removed from the menu twice, most recently in early 2024. Its return in 2021 brought changes that weren’t warmly received; a price hike and a new recipe left many members missing the original. Today, those who crave the classic churro must settle for buying them frozen and in bulk from the store—a poor consolation for those who remember them fresh and warm.
The Decadent Hand-Dipped Ice Cream Bar
A decade ago, Costco members said farewell to the hand-dipped ice cream bar, a delightful treat of vanilla ice cream coated in chocolate and optionally rolled in almonds. The rising costs of almonds and dairy were rumored contributors to its discontinuation. While a similar product exists in the frozen aisle, fans lament that the store-bought version lacks the generous, messy charm of the freshly dipped ice cream bar once available at the food court.
The Short-Lived Strawberry Ice Cream Cup
Introduced in 2023 and discontinued less than a year later, the strawberry ice cream cup fell victim to the classic vanilla versus chocolate debate, with chocolate inevitably winning space in the food court’s soft-serve machines. This decision was met with mixed reactions, depending on one’s flavor preference, and illustrates the challenging decisions Costco has to make in balancing its menu offerings.
The Robust Polish Hot Dog
Alongside the iconic hot dog and soda combo, Costco once offered a Polish hot dog, noted for its thicker, smokier flavor. Removed in 2018 to make room for healthier options, this item’s absence is still mourned by fans of its rich taste. Those longing for its return have to settle for purchasing Kirkland Signature Beef Polish Sausages from the freezer section and recreating the experience at home.
The Sugary Cinnamon Sugar Pretzel
Before the churro took its place, the cinnamon sugar pretzel was a go-to snack for those with a sweet tooth. Its removal remains shrouded in mystery, with no official explanation given, though it’s likely due to shifting consumer preferences or operational efficiencies.
The Hearty Barbecue Beef Brisket Sandwich
Introduced in November 2013 and discontinued years later, the barbecue beef brisket sandwich, with its tender meat and tangy sauce, was a hit at select locations. However, its complex preparation and nutritional profile, loaded with fat and sodium, may have contributed to its removal from the food court menu.
The Acai Bowl Experiment
In a nod to healthier options, the acai bowl replaced the Polish hot dog in 2018 but didn’t last long. Despite its promise of a refreshing, nutritious snack, customer feedback ranged from lukewarm to downright displeased, leading to its discontinuation in 2020.
The Organic Cheeseburger
Lastly, the organic cheeseburger, available only in select locations, was phased out after a short run. Despite favorable comparisons to gourmet fast-food offerings, operational challenges and costs likely led to its removal.
Each of these discontinued items tells a story of changing consumer tastes, operational decisions, and economic factors. For many Costco members, the food court is not just a place to grab a quick bite—it’s a highlight of their shopping experience, where each discontinued item leaves a legacy of collective memories and shared meals. Whether any of these favorites will make a comeback remains uncertain, but the hope and nostalgia persist, keeping the legend of these treats alive in the aisles of Costco.
