Close this search box.

Why Sam’s Club Plus Membership Outshines Costco Executive Membership

When it comes to choosing a wholesale club membership, the battle between Sam’s Club and Costco is a familiar one to many shoppers. Both clubs offer basic and premium membership options, but a closer look reveals that Sam’s Club Plus membership might just edge out Costco’s Executive Membership in terms of value and perks. Here’s a detailed breakdown of why Sam’s Club Plus could be the better choice for savvy shoppers looking for more than just savings.

1. Unmatched Online Shopping Benefits

One of the standout advantages of the Sam’s Club Plus membership is its superior online shopping benefits. Plus members enjoy free shipping on most items purchased online, a perk that extends to all complimentary cardholders on the account. This can lead to significant savings, especially for frequent online shoppers who prefer the convenience of having items delivered directly to their door.

Unlike Costco, which often charges more for online items and adds shipping fees through its partnership with Instacart, Sam’s Club does not tack on extra charges for online purchases. This means the price you see in-store is the price you pay online, providing transparency and predictability in budgeting your household expenses.

2. Early Shopping Hours

For those who prefer to shop in a less crowded environment or want to ensure they get first pick of new sales and promotions, Sam’s Club Plus membership offers an invaluable perk: early shopping hours. Plus members can enter the store at 8:00 a.m., well before the regular opening times. This exclusive access allows for a more relaxed shopping experience and is especially appealing during busy holiday seasons or for those who need to shop without the rush.

Costco Executive members, on the other hand, do not enjoy this benefit, as they are restricted to regular club hours, which can often mean navigating through more crowded aisles and potentially longer checkout lines.

3. More Flexible Cash Back Options

Both Sam’s Club and Costco offer a 2% cash back reward on qualifying purchases, but how you can use that cash back differs significantly between the two. Sam’s Club Plus caps the annual cash back at $500 but makes the funds available monthly, directly deposited into your account and ready to use immediately. This immediacy can be particularly advantageous for managing monthly budgets or saving for specific goals.

Conversely, Costco’s Executive membership allows you to earn up to $1,000 annually but issues rewards only once a year via a certificate that must be redeemed in-store. For those who prefer more frequent access to their earned rewards, Sam’s Club offers a clear advantage.

4. Prescription Savings

Healthcare costs can add up quickly, making prescription savings an important factor for many families. Sam’s Club Plus membership excels in this area by offering free generic prescriptions on select medications, along with more than 600 drugs available for $10 or less. These benefits can lead to substantial savings over time, particularly for those with regular medication needs.

While Costco also offers a member prescription program with competitive prices, the lack of additional prescription discounts tied to its Executive membership makes Sam’s Club the more appealing option for those looking to maximize their health care savings.

Conclusion: Weighing Your Options

When weighing the benefits of each membership, the Sam’s Club Plus membership clearly offers more perks that can enhance both your shopping experience and your budget. From the convenience of free shipping to the tangible benefits of early store access and better cash-back options, Sam’s Club caters to the needs of diverse shoppers.

If these perks align with your shopping habits and financial goals, transitioning from a Costco Executive membership to Sam’s Club Plus might just be a smart financial move. For those considering a switch, remember that you can cancel your Costco membership at any time and receive a refund, allowing you to make a seamless transition to Sam’s Club Plus and start enjoying these unique benefits immediately.