Close this search box.

Thatchers and Aldi’s Fizzy Legal Battle Over Lemon-Flavored Brews

Credit: BBC

In a twist that could rival any daytime soap opera, Thatchers, a brewery with a heritage as rich as its cider, found itself in a High Court tussle with supermarket giant Aldi. Picture this: a courtroom drama, but instead of lawyers in stiff suits, imagine barrels of cider and a hint of lemon zest in the air. The issue at hand? A battle of the brews over who gets to claim the throne of Cloudy Lemon Cider.

Our story begins in the picturesque Somerset countryside, home to Thatchers, a family-run cider business steeped in 120 years of apple-pressing history. In one corner, we have Thatchers, proudly flying the flag for their Cloudy Lemon Cider, a concoction they say was born from keen consumer insight and a splash of innovation. Enter the challenger, Aldi, with their Taurus cider, strutting onto the scene in May 2022. Thatchers cried foul, claiming Aldi’s Taurus was “riding on the coat-tails” of their reputation and confusing the cider-loving public.

In the other corner, Aldi, the supermarket behemoth known for its budget-friendly deals, stood its ground. With a wink and a nudge, an Aldi spokesperson quipped, “There’s nothing cloudy about this judgement. It’s clear cut.” They argued that their Taurus cider was simply inspired by Thatchers but not a copycat. Picture Aldi as the cheeky new kid on the block, shaking up the traditional cider scene.

The case found its way to the grand stage of the High Court, where Judge Melissa Clarke, in a scene that probably didn’t resemble a wine tasting event but we wish it did, conducted a blind taste test. Her verdict? A “low degree of similarity” between the two ciders. The courtroom might have lacked the drama of a reality TV show reveal, but it was a momentous occasion nonetheless.

Martin Thatcher, the fourth-generation cider wizard, expressed his disappointment but remained unshaken. “We were compelled to bring this case,” he said, standing tall like a true cider crusader. He spoke of Thatchers’ dedication to crafting cider that’s as premium as a top hat at a royal wedding. Despite the ruling, Thatcher’s passion for cider innovation was as fizzy as ever.

Aldi, meanwhile, remained as cool as a chilled glass of cider on a summer’s day. “Aldi exclusive brands are just that: exclusive to Aldi, while leading the market on quality and price,” a spokesperson said, probably with a slight smirk. The supermarket continued to assert its position as the savvy shopper’s haven, where exclusivity meets affordability.

Judge Clarke, in her wisdom, found that while Aldi’s product might remind one of Thatchers’, there was no danger of customers confusing the two. It was, in her view, a case of two distinctly different drinks, each with its own story to tell.

The judge also concluded that Aldi wasn’t trying to hijack Thatchers’ hard-earned reputation. She suggested that the claim of Aldi gaining an unfair advantage was more speculation than fact. It was a ruling that might have had less fizz than Thatchers hoped for.

Despite the verdict, Mr. Thatcher remained as steadfast as an apple tree in an English orchard. “It’s clear to us that Aldi was intent on creating a product that rides on the premium position of Thatchers,” he declared, undeterred by the court’s decision. His commitment to continuing the legacy of Thatchers’ premium ciders was as unshakable as ever.

So, what’s the takeaway from this fizzy fiasco? Whether you’re Team Thatchers or Team Aldi, one thing’s for sure: the cider world is as lively and competitive as ever. It’s a tale of tradition versus innovation, of David and Goliath, all wrapped up in a lemony zest. As the leaves turn and the days grow warmer, cider lovers everywhere will raise a glass to this spirited battle of the brews.