Close this search box.

A Pie So Good At Aldi, You’ll Swear It’s Grandma’s Secret Recipe!

Welcome to my deliciously daring adventure, where I bravely venture into the wild aisles of Aldi in search of the holy grail of desserts: a pie so scrumptious, it could fool even the most discerning of grandmothers. As a self-proclaimed Aldi aficionado and pie enthusiast, I embarked on a quest that would make Indiana Jones proud – to find the ultimate pie that screams homemade without the hassle of, well, actually making it at home.

And ladies and gentlemen, I present to you the champion of my taste-testing saga:

Bake Shop Dutch Apple Pie with Cinnamon, $3.49 for an 8-inch Pie

This isn’t just any pie; it’s the pie. Imagine a dinner where the apple pie steals the show, leaving even the turkey a little jealous. Found in Aldi’s bakery section, this sugary, crumble-topped masterpiece is what Dutch apple pies dream of becoming when they grow up.

Let’s dissect this culinary marvel, shall we? The crust is tender, like a gentle hug from your favorite aunt. The spiced apple filling is the epitome of autumn, each bite a reminder of crisp, colorful leaves and cozy sweaters. And the crumble topping? Oh, the crumble topping! It’s like a sweet, buttery encore that leaves you clapping for more.

Now, for an extra dash of pizzazz, sprinkle some freshly grated nutmeg over the top before serving. It’s like putting a top hat on an already well-dressed gentleman. And remember, folks, serving pie without ice cream is like wearing socks with sandals – a fashion faux pas. So go à la mode or go home!

If you’re going to trust one pie to grace your table this year (be it from Aldi or any other store), let it be this Dutch apple delight. For less than the price of a fancy coffee, you can serve a dessert that comfortably feeds at least six people, or one very determined pie enthusiast.

In conclusion, this pie isn’t just a dessert; it’s a statement. It’s Aldi’s mic drop in the great bake-off. So go ahead, take all the credit for this “homemade” wonder. Your secret’s safe with me. Just remember to save me a slice – or six.